Member-only story

The Astonishing Return of Martin Guerre: A Tale of Identity, Deception, and Justice

George Hayes

·8.5k Followers· Follow

Published in The Return Of Martin Guerre

6 min read · 2 weeks before

555 View Claps

59 Respond

Save

Listen

The Return of Martin Guerre

by Natalie Zemon Davis

4.5 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	2201 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Print length	:	162 pages

The Disappearance of Martin Guerre

In the year 1548, in the small village of Artigat in southwestern France, a young man named Martin Guerre left his home to fight in the Italian Wars. He was accompanied by his brother, Pierre, and they joined a regiment of French soldiers under the command of the renowned captain, Blaise de Montluc.

The war was a brutal and bloody affair, and the Guerre brothers saw their fair share of action. They fought in several major battles, including the siege of Parma and the battle of Ceresole. In 1556, Pierre was killed in action, and Martin was severely wounded. He was discharged from the army and made his way back to Artigat, where he was greeted with joy by his wife, Bertrande de Rols, and their two sons.

The Return of "Martin Guerre"

Martin's return was a cause for celebration in Artigat. He was a respected member of the community, and his family and friends were overjoyed to have him back. However, as the weeks and months passed, some people began to notice that Martin had changed. He was more withdrawn and taciturn than before, and he seemed to have lost some of his memories.

Bertrande was the first to express her doubts about her husband's identity. She claimed that he no longer recognized their children and that he had forgotten many of the details of their life together. She also noticed that he had a scar on his arm that Martin had never had before.

The Trial

Bertrande's suspicions were shared by others in the village, and soon a formal complaint was lodged against Martin. He was arrested and charged with impersonating the real Martin Guerre.

The trial that followed was one of the most sensational in French history. It lasted for several months, and witnesses from all over the region were called to testify. The evidence against Martin was damning. Several people testified that he had confessed to being an imposter, and a handwriting expert declared that his signature on a document was not the same as the signature of the real Martin Guerre.

Despite the overwhelming evidence against him, Martin steadfastly maintained his innocence. He claimed that he was the real Martin Guerre and that he had been the victim of a conspiracy by his enemies.

The Verdict

In the end, the court found Martin guilty of impersonating the real Martin Guerre. He was sentenced to death by hanging.

Martin's execution was a public spectacle. He was hanged in the town square of Artigat, and his body was left on display for several days as a warning to others.

The Real Martin Guerre

Just a few months after Martin's execution, the real Martin Guerre returned to Artigat. He had been captured by the Spanish during the war and had been held as a prisoner for several years.

When Martin returned to his village, he was greeted with disbelief. People had already executed the man they believed to be him, and they were unwilling to accept that the real Martin Guerre had returned.

Martin eventually convinced the villagers of his true identity, and he was reunited with his wife and children. He lived in Artigat for the rest of his life, and he died in 1589.

The Legacy of Martin Guerre

The story of Martin Guerre is a fascinating and complex one that has been the subject of numerous books, articles, and films. It is a tale of identity, deception, and justice that continues to captivate people to this day.

The case of Martin Guerre has also had a significant impact on the legal system. It was one of the first cases in which handwriting analysis was used as evidence in a criminal trial, and it helped to establish the principle that a person can be convicted of a crime even if they are not the actual perpetrator.

The story of Martin Guerre is a reminder that even in the most seemingly straightforward cases, the truth can be elusive. It is a story that will continue to be told and retold for generations to come.

The Return of Martin Guerre

by Natalie Zemon Davis

4.5 out of 5